This issue surfaced only because someone ran a slow suite that is
excluded by default and had not been run for eighteen days. As a column
it becomes a query: which model stopped being observable, and when.
The emitter unwraps the enum to a plain str at the single _record exit.
asyncpg makes no promise about encoding a str subclass, and a telemetry
write that fails is downgraded to one warning — it would not crash, it
would just quietly cost the Postgres path a column. Normalising at the
emitter follows what tenant_id, meta and sampling already do.
The column is appended last in COLUMNS and in both DDLs. An existing
table can only take ALTER at the end, so putting it anywhere else
forks the physical column order between a freshly built database and a
backfilled one.
Telemetry degradation used to be a single warning and a private boolean.
In a long-running process that is indistinguishable from telemetry working:
issue #15 was only found by hand-reconciling milestone log lines against
llm_calls rows, after 19 calls had silently gone unrecorded. The SQLite
side was worse — once init failed, every write returned without even a
log line.
Degradation now has one shared owner. TelemetryStatusTracker holds the
state machine (enter/recover/drop/should-retry), announces entry and
recovery once each, and repeats the drop count under a row-and-time
double threshold so a degraded backend neither floods the log nor goes
quiet. Both recorders hold one; both count the rows they drop.
For programmatic consumers, TelemetryStatus is a frozen snapshot exposed
as telemetry_status on all three clients, resolved through a single
isinstance check. It is a separate optional port rather than a member of
TelemetryRecorder: that protocol is @runtime_checkable, so adding an
attribute would make every implementation that only defines
record_llm_call stop satisfying it — downstream isinstance assertions
would break on upgrade. The existing assertion in test_ports.py is what
keeps that decision honest.
Failure criteria are deliberately untouched here: Postgres still treats a
pool failure as permanent, only now visibly. `_failed` and the tracker
therefore both carry the verdict for the span of this one change; the
cooldown rework collapses them into the tracker alone.
Both telemetry backends gain tenant_id and meta at the end of the
column list, and TelemetryEmitter fills them from the request. The two
halves ship together because the emitter is the only caller of
record_llm_call: adding the columns without filling them leaves every
row short of two keys, and the backends read those keys outside their
try block, so the KeyError degrades to a warning and the whole table
stops filling.
The columns are appended, never inserted. An old table can only gain
columns through ALTER, which puts them last; a new table built from the
DDL would put them wherever the DDL says. Anywhere but the end and the
two paths produce different physical column orders, while the INSERT
uses positional placeholders.
The two backends spell the default differently for different reasons.
SQLite refuses a NOT NULL column without a non-NULL constant default
outright, so the default is what makes the backfill legal at all. On
Postgres a non-volatile constant default is what keeps the ALTER from
rewriting the table, and NOT NULL DEFAULT '' is what keeps old rows out
of the black hole a NULL tenant_id falls into under an RLS policy.
Normalisation happens in the emitter, not the recorder, matching how
canonical_sampling_json already settles the sampling column: None
becomes the empty string, an empty mapping becomes the literal '{}'.
Keys are sorted so one set of dimensions serialises identically on
every row, and allow_nan=False is a second gate behind the entry
validation -- json.dumps would otherwise write a bare NaN, which JSONB
rejects, and the failed insert would be swallowed as a warning.
All three emit entry points read the request. Cache hits read it too,
rather than the replayed response: the dimensions answer who made this
call, not who made the one whose result is being replayed.
Three README drifts, none of them about issue #8 alone:
- the telemetry row said 18 fields; record_llm_call takes 22 (verified by
inspect.signature). ports.py claimed 20 in its own docstring, so both
records of the same fact were stale.
- LLMResponse.cost is hardcoded to None on the chat path (retry.py:519).
Cost only ever reaches telemetry. The old doc site named this as a known
trap, so the capability row now says it outright.
- backpressure had no row at all, which is what issue #8 was about.
Reasoning tokens are already counted inside completion_tokens, so the
cost total was never wrong -- what was missing is the attribution: how
much of a call was spent thinking rather than answering.
LLMResponse and TransportResult each gain a trailing reasoning_tokens
field, and the telemetry port grows from 21 to 22 columns with the new
column appended in both backends so fresh and migrated schemas keep the
same physical order.
None means this particular call did not report the field, not that the
source never reports it: a relay that falls back to a local tokenizer
replaces the whole usage object and drops completion_tokens_details.
Downstream checks must therefore read "in (None, 0)"; no provider was
observed reporting a literal zero.
Round 3 showed unconditional yield-after-two-failures pushes the third
attempt onto known-bad sources in heterogeneous pools (83% vs 10%
expected success). OutcomeAwareSelector now exposes health(); a failed
source only yields when some untried candidate scores at least half its
health. Health-blind selectors keep the unconditional rule.
RetryMW keeps a per-call failure map (local, never instance state):
a source failing twice in one call yields to the next candidate.
Attempt outcomes feed OutcomeAwareSelector behind a swallow-and-warn
guard; ResultInvalid and provider-rejected paths record success with
count_attempt=False so the breaker window stays clean. Same accounting
applied in EmbeddingClient.
Score is success-rate EWMA over (1 + inflight) with a 0.05 exploration
floor so quarantined sources can prove recovery; EWMA climb doubles as
slow-start. New optional OutcomeAwareSelector port feeds attempt
outcomes.
iomgaa