"""推理裁定与对账的行为测试(issue #16/#17 设计 §4-§5)。 判据来自 2026-08-25 实测(findings): MiniMax-M3 在开启档流式路径下返回 185 字符 推理正文却不上报 `completion_tokens_details`,而 qwen/deepseek 两者都报。库因此 不能把任何单一信号当权威——本组用例逐条钉死"哪个信号该赢"。 """ import pytest from polygateway.thinking import observe_thinking from polygateway.types import ThinkingObservation class TestObserveThinking: """三态裁定: 证据硬度决定优先级,无信号一律 UNKNOWN。""" def test_reasoning_text_alone_proves_it_happened(self): """推理正文是事实本身: 上游不报 token 数也照样成立(M3 流式实测形态)。""" assert ( observe_thinking(thinking="先解方程 x+y=35", reasoning_tokens=None) is ThinkingObservation.OBSERVED ) def test_blank_text_is_not_evidence(self): """纯空白正文不算证据: 网关响应是外部输入,truthy 判据会把空格计成推理(P5)。""" assert ( observe_thinking(thinking=" \n\t ", reasoning_tokens=None) is ThinkingObservation.UNKNOWN ) def test_positive_token_count_proves_it_happened(self): """无正文但上游报了推理用量(qwen 非流式形态)。""" assert ( observe_thinking(thinking="", reasoning_tokens=205) is ThinkingObservation.OBSERVED ) def test_zero_token_count_is_positive_evidence_of_absence(self): """`0` 是"上报了且为零",与"没上报"语义不同,故是 ABSENT 而非 UNKNOWN。""" assert observe_thinking(thinking="", reasoning_tokens=0) is ThinkingObservation.ABSENT def test_no_signal_at_all_stays_unknown(self): """M3 非流式开启档的真实形态: 推理已计费却既无正文也无 token 数。 判成 ABSENT 就是伪装成"没推理"——正是 issue #16/#17 的病根。 """ assert observe_thinking(thinking="", reasoning_tokens=None) is ThinkingObservation.UNKNOWN def test_text_outranks_a_zero_count(self): """转述与事实冲突时事实赢: 正文在,`reasoning_tokens=0` 不能翻案。""" assert ( observe_thinking(thinking="想了想", reasoning_tokens=0) is ThinkingObservation.OBSERVED ) class TestThinkingObservationEnum: def test_values_are_stable_strings(self): """取值进遥测落库,改名即历史数据断层。""" assert ThinkingObservation.OBSERVED == "observed" assert ThinkingObservation.ABSENT == "absent" assert ThinkingObservation.UNKNOWN == "unknown" def test_enum_lives_in_the_innermost_layer(self): """枚举必须定义在 `types.py`(最内层)。 它是 `LLMResponse` 的字段类型;定义在决策层 `thinking.py` 会让 `types.py` 反向 import 决策模块,违反 P7 依赖铁律(import-linter 契约执法)。 """ assert ThinkingObservation.__module__ == "polygateway.types" @pytest.mark.parametrize("bogus", ["", "OBSERVED", "yes", "none"]) def test_unknown_strings_are_rejected(bogus): """非法值必须抛 ValueError: 缓存回放靠它把污染数据挡成"未命中"(设计 §6)。""" with pytest.raises(ValueError): ThinkingObservation(bogus)