Files
Video-Tree-TRM5/research-wiki/plans/2026-07-14-action-recognition-strategy.md
T
2026-07-14 06:34:40 -04:00

30 KiB
Raw Blame History

ActionRecognitionStrategy 特化实现计划 (Plan B)

For agentic workers: REQUIRED SUB-SKILL: Use subagent-driven-development to implement this plan task-by-task. Steps use checkbox (- [ ]) syntax for tracking.

Goal: 实现 ActionRecognitionStrategy 特化策略(6 个 SubPattern + AR 专属 prompt),替换 Plan A 中 AR 的临时 VISUAL_FAMILY 绑定,使 AR 出题靶向 22 道错题的 6 种失败子模式。

Architecture: 新建 strategy_action_recognition.pyActionRecognitionStrategy 类 + 6 个 SubPattern 定义),新建 action_recognition.md prompt 模板,在 strategy.py 的模块初始化中注册。Pipeline 无需改动 —— Plan A 已接好全部 sub_pattern 接口(instructionsampling_level_overrideconstraint_override)。

Tech Stack: Python 3.11, pytest, Protocol (typing)

关联设计: research-wiki/designs/2026-07-14-task-type-strategy-design.md §4

范围: 仅 Plan BActionRecognitionStrategy 特化)。不改 pipeline、sampler、generator、gates、store。


Task 1: AR 专属 prompt 模板

Files:

  • Create: store/prompts/question_gen/action_recognition.md

  • Step 1: 创建 AR 专属 prompt 模板

You are a question generator for video understanding benchmarks, specializing in **Action Recognition**.

Your task: Generate a multiple-choice question that tests whether the answerer can accurately recognize, distinguish, and reason about **actions and behaviors** observed across multiple segments of the video.

## Action Recognition Guidelines

- The question MUST require watching multiple segments or the full video — single-frame-answerable questions are failures.
- Focus on **dynamic actions**: what someone does, how they do it, the sequence of actions, or which action is absent.
- The correct answer must be grounded in observable behavior (body movements, interactions, operations), NOT in static visual attributes or text/OCR.
- Questions should target action details that require temporal tracking: order of events, manner of execution, repetition counts, or cross-segment entity behavior.

## Quality Requirements

- Question must be grammatically correct and unambiguous.
- All four options must be parallel in structure and length.
- The correct answer must not be identifiable from linguistic cues alone.
- Each option must begin with "A. ", "B. ", "C. ", or "D. ".

## Prohibited Patterns

- Do NOT generate questions answerable from a single frame or screenshot — if pausing the video at one moment gives the answer, the question is too easy.
- Do NOT generate OCR/text-reading questions disguised as action recognition — reading jersey numbers, scoreboards, or on-screen text is NOT action recognition.
- Do NOT fabricate actions not observable in the provided material.
- Do NOT construct options where the correct answer is obvious from common sense or world knowledge alone.
- Do NOT write questions where multiple options could reasonably be correct.

## Output

Respond with ONLY a valid JSON object. No additional text.
  • Step 2: 验证模板可加载
conda run -n Video-Tree-TRM python -c "
from app.question_gen.generator_v2 import _load_prompt_template
content = _load_prompt_template('action_recognition.md')
assert 'Action Recognition' in content
print('OK: action_recognition.md loaded successfully')
"

预期:打印 OK 消息,无异常。

  • Step 3: 提交
git add store/prompts/question_gen/action_recognition.md
git commit -m "feat(question_gen): add Action Recognition specialized prompt template"

Task 2: ActionRecognitionStrategy 类 + 6 个 SubPattern

Files:

  • Create: app/question_gen/strategy_action_recognition.py

  • Test: tests/unit/test_strategy_action_recognition.py

  • Step 1: 写失败测试

# tests/unit/test_strategy_action_recognition.py
"""ActionRecognitionStrategy 单元测试。"""

from __future__ import annotations

import random

import pytest

from app.question_gen.strategy_action_recognition import (
    AR_SUB_PATTERNS,
    ActionRecognitionStrategy,
)


class TestActionRecognitionStrategy:
    """ActionRecognitionStrategy 属性和行为。"""

    @pytest.fixture
    def strategy(self) -> ActionRecognitionStrategy:
        """创建策略实例。"""
        return ActionRecognitionStrategy()

    def test_task_type(self, strategy: ActionRecognitionStrategy) -> None:
        """task_type 固定为 Action Recognition。"""
        assert strategy.task_type == "Action Recognition"

    def test_strategy_name(self, strategy: ActionRecognitionStrategy) -> None:
        """strategy_name 为 ACTION_RECOGNITION。"""
        assert strategy.strategy_name == "ACTION_RECOGNITION"

    def test_skill_target(self, strategy: ActionRecognitionStrategy) -> None:
        """skill_target 为 M1_AR。"""
        assert strategy.skill_target == "M1_AR"

    def test_sampling_level(self, strategy: ActionRecognitionStrategy) -> None:
        """默认采样层级为 L2。"""
        assert strategy.sampling_level == 2

    def test_sampling_constraint(self, strategy: ActionRecognitionStrategy) -> None:
        """采样约束加强:min_subtitles=3, min_l3_nodes=5, require_frames=True, cross_l2_span=True。"""
        c = strategy.sampling_constraint
        assert c.min_subtitles == 3
        assert c.min_l3_nodes == 5
        assert c.require_frames is True
        assert c.cross_l2_span is True

    def test_prompt_template(self, strategy: ActionRecognitionStrategy) -> None:
        """使用 AR 专属 prompt 模板。"""
        assert strategy.prompt_template == "action_recognition.md"

    def test_leak_probe_template(self, strategy: ActionRecognitionStrategy) -> None:
        """复用 RETRIEVAL 的泄漏检测模板。"""
        assert strategy.leak_probe_template == "gate_leak_retrieval.md"

    def test_extra_gates_empty(self, strategy: ActionRecognitionStrategy) -> None:
        """当前版本无额外 gate。"""
        assert strategy.extra_gates(None) == []


class TestSubPatternSelection:
    """select_sub_pattern 行为。"""

    @pytest.fixture
    def strategy(self) -> ActionRecognitionStrategy:
        return ActionRecognitionStrategy()

    def test_returns_sub_pattern(self, strategy: ActionRecognitionStrategy) -> None:
        """select_sub_pattern 返回 SubPattern 而非 None。"""
        rng = random.Random(42)
        sp = strategy.select_sub_pattern(rng)
        assert sp is not None
        assert sp.name in [p.name for p in AR_SUB_PATTERNS]

    def test_deterministic_with_same_seed(self, strategy: ActionRecognitionStrategy) -> None:
        """相同 seed 返回相同 SubPattern。"""
        sp1 = strategy.select_sub_pattern(random.Random(42))
        sp2 = strategy.select_sub_pattern(random.Random(42))
        assert sp1.name == sp2.name

    def test_distribution_covers_all_patterns(self, strategy: ActionRecognitionStrategy) -> None:
        """足够多次采样应覆盖全部 6 个子模式。"""
        rng = random.Random(123)
        names = {strategy.select_sub_pattern(rng).name for _ in range(200)}
        assert len(names) == 6

    def test_sub_pattern_has_instruction(self, strategy: ActionRecognitionStrategy) -> None:
        """每个 SubPattern 都有非空 instruction。"""
        for sp in AR_SUB_PATTERNS:
            assert sp.instruction.strip(), f"{sp.name} 的 instruction 为空"

    def test_sub_pattern_has_distractor_rules(self, strategy: ActionRecognitionStrategy) -> None:
        """每个 SubPattern 都有非空 distractor_rules。"""
        for sp in AR_SUB_PATTERNS:
            assert sp.distractor_rules.strip(), f"{sp.name} 的 distractor_rules 为空"


class TestSubPatternOverrides:
    """SubPattern 的 sampling 覆盖。"""

    def test_l1_patterns_override_level(self) -> None:
        """L1 子模式覆盖默认的 L2 采样层级。"""
        l1_names = {"premature_evidence_anchoring", "temporal_reasoning_failure", "cross_segment_entity_tracking"}
        for sp in AR_SUB_PATTERNS:
            if sp.name in l1_names:
                assert sp.sampling_level_override == 1, f"{sp.name} 应覆盖为 L1"
            else:
                assert sp.sampling_level_override is None, f"{sp.name} 不应覆盖采样层级"

    def test_weights_sum_to_one(self) -> None:
        """权重总和为 1.0。"""
        total = sum(sp.weight for sp in AR_SUB_PATTERNS)
        assert abs(total - 1.0) < 1e-9

    def test_individual_weights_match_design(self) -> None:
        """每个子模式权重与设计文档一致。"""
        expected = {
            "premature_evidence_anchoring": 0.20,
            "temporal_reasoning_failure": 0.20,
            "semantic_rigidity": 0.15,
            "fine_grained_visual_action": 0.15,
            "cross_segment_entity_tracking": 0.15,
            "evidence_gap_confabulation": 0.15,
        }
        for sp in AR_SUB_PATTERNS:
            assert abs(sp.weight - expected[sp.name]) < 1e-9, f"{sp.name} 权重不匹配"

    def test_all_six_patterns_defined(self) -> None:
        """定义了 6 个子模式。"""
        assert len(AR_SUB_PATTERNS) == 6
        expected_names = {
            "premature_evidence_anchoring",
            "temporal_reasoning_failure",
            "semantic_rigidity",
            "fine_grained_visual_action",
            "cross_segment_entity_tracking",
            "evidence_gap_confabulation",
        }
        actual_names = {sp.name for sp in AR_SUB_PATTERNS}
        assert actual_names == expected_names
  • Step 2: 运行测试验证失败
conda run -n Video-Tree-TRM pytest tests/unit/test_strategy_action_recognition.py -v

预期:ImportError — app.question_gen.strategy_action_recognition 不存在。

  • Step 3: 实现 strategy_action_recognition.py
# app/question_gen/strategy_action_recognition.py
"""Action Recognition 特化出题策略 — 靶向 6 种失败子模式。

来源:22 道 VME AR 错题双分类器仲裁分析。
每个 SubPattern 定义独立的 instruction、采样覆盖、干扰项构造规则,
由 pipeline 在出题时注入到 prompt 的 Special Focus 区段。

设计文档: research-wiki/designs/2026-07-14-task-type-strategy-design.md §4
"""

from __future__ import annotations

from typing import TYPE_CHECKING, Any

from app.question_gen.families import SamplingConstraint
from app.question_gen.strategy import SubPattern

if TYPE_CHECKING:
    import random


# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# 默认采样约束(设计文档 §4 定义)
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------

_AR_DEFAULT_CONSTRAINT = SamplingConstraint(
    min_subtitles=3,
    min_l3_nodes=5,
    require_frames=True,
    cross_l2_span=True,
)

# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# 6 个 SubPattern 定义
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------

_SP_PREMATURE_EVIDENCE_ANCHORING = SubPattern(
    name="premature_evidence_anchoring",
    weight=0.20,
    sampling_level_override=1,
    constraint_override=None,
    instruction=(
        "Generate a question where the correct answer requires verifying evidence across "
        "ALL options before committing — not just finding one matching piece of evidence. "
        "The video must contain a plausible-looking but incorrect match that appears early "
        "or prominently, while the true answer is confirmed only by cross-referencing "
        "multiple segments. The question should punish an agent that stops searching after "
        "the first evidence match."
    ),
    positive_examples=[
        {
            "question": "Which of the following tasks did the heroine not complete while her baby was sleeping?",
            "answer": "D. Doing laundry",
            "why": "Requires checking all 4 options against all segments; stopping at first match misses the negation.",
        },
        {
            "question": "Which acrobatic skill is absent from this video?",
            "answer": "D. Somersault",
            "why": "Must verify every option against every segment to confirm absence.",
        },
    ],
    negative_examples=[
        {
            "question": "What color jersey does the player wear?",
            "why": "Single-frame answerable, no need to verify across segments.",
        },
    ],
    distractor_rules=(
        "Place the most visually salient or early-appearing action as a distractor (not the answer). "
        "Make one distractor partially correct (happens in a different segment or by a different person). "
        "The correct answer should require exhaustive verification across segments."
    ),
)

_SP_TEMPORAL_REASONING_FAILURE = SubPattern(
    name="temporal_reasoning_failure",
    weight=0.20,
    sampling_level_override=1,
    constraint_override=None,
    instruction=(
        "Generate a question that requires precise temporal ordering or locating the Nth "
        "occurrence of an event. The video must contain the same or similar action happening "
        "multiple times, and the question must specify a temporal anchor (e.g., 'after X happens', "
        "'the second time', 'at the beginning'). The correct answer depends on getting the "
        "sequence order right."
    ),
    positive_examples=[
        {
            "question": "In the video after feeding the ducks, what did the male protagonist do after riding his bike?",
            "answer": "A. Went jogging in the park",
            "why": "Requires precise temporal chain: feeding → biking → next action.",
        },
        {
            "question": "What happened to the team on the counterattack after Sabonis' first steal?",
            "answer": "D. They scored a three-pointer",
            "why": "Must locate the FIRST steal (not second) and track what follows.",
        },
    ],
    negative_examples=[
        {
            "question": "What does the person do in the video?",
            "why": "No temporal anchor, any observation suffices.",
        },
    ],
    distractor_rules=(
        "Include actions that genuinely occur in the video but at a different time point. "
        "One distractor should be what happens before the anchored moment. "
        "Another should be what happens after the Nth+1 occurrence (off-by-one trap)."
    ),
)

_SP_SEMANTIC_RIGIDITY = SubPattern(
    name="semantic_rigidity",
    weight=0.15,
    sampling_level_override=None,
    constraint_override=None,
    instruction=(
        "Generate a question where the correct answer option uses a synonym, paraphrase, or "
        "semantic equivalent of what is shown in the video — NOT the exact words from subtitles. "
        "The agent must recognize that a rephrased description matches the observed action. "
        "Include a distractor that uses near-verbatim subtitle wording but describes a "
        "different or incorrect action."
    ),
    positive_examples=[
        {
            "question": "What are the magic tricks about?",
            "answer": "B. Sleight of hand with everyday objects",
            "why": "Video shows card and coin manipulation; correct answer paraphrases rather than quoting subtitles.",
        },
    ],
    negative_examples=[
        {
            "question": "According to the narrator, what is the main topic?",
            "why": "Invites verbatim subtitle matching, not semantic understanding.",
        },
    ],
    distractor_rules=(
        "One distractor must reuse exact subtitle phrasing but apply it to the wrong action/context. "
        "Another distractor should use a semantically related but distinct action verb "
        "(e.g., 'cutting' vs 'slicing' vs 'chopping' when only one is correct). "
        "The correct answer must be a valid semantic equivalent, not a stretch."
    ),
)

_SP_FINE_GRAINED_VISUAL_ACTION = SubPattern(
    name="fine_grained_visual_action",
    weight=0.15,
    sampling_level_override=None,
    constraint_override=None,
    instruction=(
        "Generate a question that distinguishes between visually similar actions — "
        "the MANNER of how something is done, not just WHAT is done. "
        "The video must show a specific technique, method, or style of performing an action, "
        "and the question must test whether the agent can differentiate it from similar alternatives. "
        "Frames are essential — the answer cannot come from subtitles alone."
    ),
    positive_examples=[
        {
            "question": "How does the chef prepare the garlic in this recipe?",
            "answer": "C. Crushes it with the flat side of a knife",
            "why": "All options are valid garlic preparations; only visual observation distinguishes.",
        },
        {
            "question": "What does the man with a laughing face do at the beginning of the video?",
            "answer": "C. Clasps his hands together and bows",
            "why": "Specific gesture detail requires frame-level observation.",
        },
    ],
    negative_examples=[
        {
            "question": "Does the person cook in the video?",
            "why": "Binary yes/no, no manner distinction needed.",
        },
    ],
    distractor_rules=(
        "All four options must describe the same general category of action "
        "(e.g., all are ways of cutting, all are types of greetings). "
        "Distractors must be visually plausible alternatives that could occur in the same context. "
        "The distinction must be observable only from frames, not from subtitles."
    ),
)

_SP_CROSS_SEGMENT_ENTITY_TRACKING = SubPattern(
    name="cross_segment_entity_tracking",
    weight=0.15,
    sampling_level_override=1,
    constraint_override=None,
    instruction=(
        "Generate a question that requires tracking a specific entity (person, object, or group) "
        "across multiple video segments and merging observations. The correct answer depends on "
        "information from at least two separate segments — a single segment gives only a partial "
        "or misleading picture. The entity must appear in different contexts or states across segments."
    ),
    positive_examples=[
        {
            "question": "In the video, what happened in the car when the heroine came home from shopping?",
            "answer": "D. The car wouldn't start and she had to call for help",
            "why": "Must track heroine across shopping segment → car segment → resolution.",
        },
    ],
    negative_examples=[
        {
            "question": "What is the person wearing?",
            "why": "Single-segment observation, no cross-segment tracking needed.",
        },
    ],
    distractor_rules=(
        "One distractor should be correct for the entity in a DIFFERENT segment (right entity, wrong time). "
        "Another distractor should be correct for a DIFFERENT entity in the same segment (right time, wrong entity). "
        "The correct answer must require merging observations from multiple segments."
    ),
)

_SP_EVIDENCE_GAP_CONFABULATION = SubPattern(
    name="evidence_gap_confabulation",
    weight=0.15,
    sampling_level_override=None,
    constraint_override=None,
    instruction=(
        "Generate a question about an action where the video evidence is INCOMPLETE — "
        "the full causal chain is not directly shown. The correct answer is the one that "
        "stays faithful to what IS observable, while distractors fill in the gap with "
        "plausible but unsupported causal narratives. The agent must resist inventing "
        "explanations for unobserved transitions."
    ),
    positive_examples=[
        {
            "question": "How were the Sawtooth ranges formed?",
            "answer": "D. The video describes geological uplift but does not show the formation process",
            "why": "Video describes result but not process; agent must not confabulate mechanism.",
        },
    ],
    negative_examples=[
        {
            "question": "Why did the person leave the room?",
            "why": "If the reason is explicitly stated in dialogue, no evidence gap exists.",
        },
    ],
    distractor_rules=(
        "Distractors must be plausible causal narratives that COULD explain the outcome but "
        "are NOT supported by the video evidence. Each distractor should fill the evidence gap "
        "with a different invented mechanism. The correct answer must be the one that "
        "either: (a) states only what is directly observable, or (b) acknowledges the limitation."
    ),
)

# 导出 tuple(不可变,按名称排序供测试)
AR_SUB_PATTERNS: tuple[SubPattern, ...] = (
    _SP_PREMATURE_EVIDENCE_ANCHORING,
    _SP_TEMPORAL_REASONING_FAILURE,
    _SP_SEMANTIC_RIGIDITY,
    _SP_FINE_GRAINED_VISUAL_ACTION,
    _SP_CROSS_SEGMENT_ENTITY_TRACKING,
    _SP_EVIDENCE_GAP_CONFABULATION,
)


# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Strategy 实现
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------


class ActionRecognitionStrategy:
    """Action Recognition 特化出题策略。

    自包含 —— 不依赖 QuestionFamilySpec,直接定义采样约束、prompt、gate 合约。
    6 个 SubPattern 按权重随机选择,各自可覆盖默认采样层级。

    设计文档: research-wiki/designs/2026-07-14-task-type-strategy-design.md §4
    """

    @property
    def task_type(self) -> str:
        """固定为 Action Recognition。"""
        return "Action Recognition"

    @property
    def sampling_level(self) -> int:
        """默认 L2 事件级(从 L3 提升,有意变更)。"""
        return 2

    @property
    def sampling_constraint(self) -> SamplingConstraint:
        """加强约束:要求字幕、帧、跨段。"""
        return _AR_DEFAULT_CONSTRAINT

    @property
    def prompt_template(self) -> str:
        """AR 专属 prompt 模板。"""
        return "action_recognition.md"

    @property
    def strategy_name(self) -> str:
        """store 的 family 字段。"""
        return "ACTION_RECOGNITION"

    @property
    def skill_target(self) -> str:
        """M1_AR — 继承 RETRIEVAL 的 M1 + AR 后缀区分。"""
        return "M1_AR"

    @property
    def leak_probe_template(self) -> str:
        """复用 RETRIEVAL 的泄漏检测模板。"""
        return "gate_leak_retrieval.md"

    def select_sub_pattern(self, rng: random.Random) -> SubPattern:
        """按权重随机选择一个子模式。

        参数:
            rng: 可控随机数生成器。

        返回:
            选中的 SubPattern 实例。
        """
        names = [sp.name for sp in AR_SUB_PATTERNS]
        weights = [sp.weight for sp in AR_SUB_PATTERNS]
        chosen_name = rng.choices(names, weights=weights, k=1)[0]
        return next(sp for sp in AR_SUB_PATTERNS if sp.name == chosen_name)

    def build_prompt_context(self, material: Any, sub_pattern: SubPattern | None) -> dict:
        """返回 AR 的 prompt 上下文。

        参数:
            material: 采样素材上下文。
            sub_pattern: 选中的子模式(AR 策略下始终非 None)。

        返回:
            上下文字典。
        """
        return {
            "family_name": "ACTION_RECOGNITION",
            "prompt_template": "action_recognition.md",
            "sub_pattern": sub_pattern.name if sub_pattern else None,
        }

    def extra_gates(self, candidate: Any) -> list:
        """当前版本无额外 gate,预留接口。

        参数:
            candidate: 候选题目。

        返回:
            空列表。
        """
        return []
  • Step 4: 运行测试验证通过
conda run -n Video-Tree-TRM pytest tests/unit/test_strategy_action_recognition.py -v

预期:全部 PASS

  • Step 5: 格式和 lint 检查
conda run -n Video-Tree-TRM ruff format app/question_gen/strategy_action_recognition.py tests/unit/test_strategy_action_recognition.py
conda run -n Video-Tree-TRM ruff check app/question_gen/strategy_action_recognition.py tests/unit/test_strategy_action_recognition.py
conda run -n Video-Tree-TRM radon cc app/question_gen/strategy_action_recognition.py -n C -s

预期:零 error,无 C 级以上复杂度。

  • Step 6: 提交
git add app/question_gen/strategy_action_recognition.py tests/unit/test_strategy_action_recognition.py
git commit -m "feat(question_gen): add ActionRecognitionStrategy with 6 SubPatterns"

Task 3: 注册 AR 策略 + 移除临时绑定

Files:

  • Modify: app/question_gen/strategy.py:107

  • Test: tests/unit/test_strategy.py(追加测试)

  • Step 1: 写测试 — AR 注册后 get_strategy 返回特化策略

tests/unit/test_strategy.py 末尾追加:

class TestActionRecognitionRegistration:
    """AR 策略注册后 get_strategy 返回特化实例。"""

    def test_get_strategy_returns_ar_strategy(self):
        """get_strategy('Action Recognition') 返回 ActionRecognitionStrategy。"""
        from app.question_gen.strategy_action_recognition import ActionRecognitionStrategy

        s = get_strategy("Action Recognition")
        assert isinstance(s, ActionRecognitionStrategy)
        assert s.task_type == "Action Recognition"
        assert s.strategy_name == "ACTION_RECOGNITION"

    def test_ar_not_base_strategy(self):
        """get_strategy('Action Recognition') 不再返回 BaseTaskTypeStrategy。"""
        s = get_strategy("Action Recognition")
        assert not isinstance(s, BaseTaskTypeStrategy)

    def test_other_types_still_base(self):
        """其他题型仍返回 BaseTaskTypeStrategy。"""
        for tt in ("Object Recognition", "Temporal Reasoning", "Spatial Reasoning"):
            s = get_strategy(tt)
            assert isinstance(s, BaseTaskTypeStrategy), f"{tt} 应该是 BaseTaskTypeStrategy"
  • Step 2: 运行测试验证失败
conda run -n Video-Tree-TRM pytest tests/unit/test_strategy.py::TestActionRecognitionRegistration -v

预期:test_get_strategy_returns_ar_strategy FAIL(返回 BaseTaskTypeStrategy)。

  • Step 3: 在 get_strategy 中添加延迟注册

修改 app/question_gen/strategy.py 中的 get_strategy 函数,在首次调用时触发特化策略注册(避免循环导入):

_BUILTIN_REGISTERED = False

def get_strategy(task_type: str) -> TaskTypeStrategy:
    """获取题型策略。未注册的自动创建 BaseTaskTypeStrategy。

    首次调用时延迟注册内建特化策略(避免循环导入)。

    参数:
        task_type: 题型名。

    返回:
        TaskTypeStrategy 实例。

    异常:
        KeyError: task_type 不在消歧绑定表和注册表中。
    """
    global _BUILTIN_REGISTERED  # noqa: PLW0603
    if not _BUILTIN_REGISTERED:
        _BUILTIN_REGISTERED = True
        _register_builtin_strategies()

    if task_type in _STRATEGY_REGISTRY:
        return _STRATEGY_REGISTRY[task_type]
    return _build_default_strategy(task_type)


def _register_builtin_strategies() -> None:
    """注册内建的特化策略。由 get_strategy 首次调用时延迟执行。"""
    from app.question_gen.strategy_action_recognition import ActionRecognitionStrategy
    register_strategy(ActionRecognitionStrategy())

同时更新 _TASK_TYPE_TO_FAMILY 中 AR 的注释:

# 修改前:
"Action Recognition": VISUAL_FAMILY,  # Plan A 临时绑定;Plan B 替换为特化策略

# 修改后:
"Action Recognition": VISUAL_FAMILY,  # fallback — 注册表中已被 ActionRecognitionStrategy 替换
  • Step 4: 运行测试验证通过
conda run -n Video-Tree-TRM pytest tests/unit/test_strategy.py tests/unit/test_strategy_action_recognition.py -v

预期:全部 PASS。

  • Step 5: 提交
git add app/question_gen/strategy.py tests/unit/test_strategy.py
git commit -m "feat(question_gen): register ActionRecognitionStrategy, replace temp VISUAL binding"

Task 4: 全量回归测试 + lint

  • Step 1: lint
conda run -n Video-Tree-TRM ruff format app/question_gen/ tests/ && conda run -n Video-Tree-TRM ruff check app/question_gen/ --fix
  • Step 2: 全量测试
conda run -n Video-Tree-TRM pytest tests/unit/ tests/integration/ -v --tb=short

预期:1173+ 全部 PASS

  • Step 3: 提交(如有 lint 修复)
git add -A && git commit -m "chore: lint and format Plan B changes"

行为保真检查清单

# 行为 状态 说明
1 11 个非 AR 题型行为不变 保留 get_strategy 对非 AR 类型仍返回 BaseTaskTypeStrategy
2 AR 从 VISUAL_FAMILY(L3) 变为 AR 特化(L2) 有意变更 设计文档 §4 明确标注
3 AR 采样约束加强 有意变更 设计文档 §4: min_subtitles=3, cross_l2_span=True
4 AR prompt 从 visual.md 变为 action_recognition.md 有意变更 专属 prompt 靶向动作识别
5 AR strategy_name 从 "VISUAL" 变为 "ACTION_RECOGNITION" 有意变更 store 中新记录可区分
6 AR skill_target 从 "M4" 变为 "M1_AR" 有意变更 设计文档 §4
7 select_sub_pattern 返回 SubPattern(非 None 有意变更 AR 始终有 sub_pattern
8 sub_pattern.instruction 注入到 prompt 保留 Plan A 已接线(generator_v2.py:176-177
9 sub_pattern.sampling_level_override 覆盖 level 保留 Plan A 已接线(pipeline_v2.py:359-360
10 sub_pattern.name 写入 store 保留 Plan A 已接线(pipeline_v2.py:425
11 pipeline 重出循环/后处理/四门 gate 不变 保留 Plan B 不改 pipeline
12 断点续跑 保留 pipeline 的 progress 机制不变

核心算法保真校验

本计划不涉及核心算法迁移,保真校验不适用。

非功能性需求

维度 设计
持久化 不变 — on_accept 逐题回调。sub_pattern 名已在 Plan A 中接入 store
幂等性 不变 — strategy 查找确定性,sub_pattern 选择由 rng 控制
断点续跑 不变 — progress 机制在 pipeline 层,strategy 无状态
原子性 不变 — 逐题落库