Same failure path as the embedding loop: one timed-out attempt drains the
wall-clock window, and the next round without a runnable source declares
the scope dead in _on_no_runnable. All three governance loops now meter
stall the same way.
The embedding loop shares the wall-clock entered_at and the same stall
verdict, so it failed the same way through a different path: one timed-out
attempt, then any round with no runnable source, and _on_no_runnable
declared the scope dead. Issue #8 only recorded the chat path; the
regression test pins this one.
Issue #8: with timeout_s >= stall_window_s a single timed-out request
exhausted the stall window before the second attempt was even dispatched,
so LLM_MAX_RETRIES never applied and the whole scope was declared dead.
Root cause is that real attempts and non-productive waiting charged the
same wall clock, while the stall budget is the smaller of the two. The new
StallClock subtracts attempt time from the stall account, leaving the two
budgets orthogonal: attempts bill max_attempts, waiting bills
stall_window_s. The dual-condition verdict, the inf semantics of
progress_age_s, the 429 exemption and the error surface are untouched.
The productive boundary is _attempt itself, telemetry included, so a slow
recorder cannot push a call into a stalled verdict.
Letting SourceNotConfiguredError through the gate wrappers opened a hole
the recheck caught: _record_quietly only degrades GovernanceBackendError,
so an assembly defect raised from the accounting side would now escape and
destroy a response from a call that had already genuinely succeeded. That
inverts the exact invariant _record_quietly exists to hold.
Widening _record_quietly is the right fix rather than narrowing the
wrappers, because that layer degrades by what the path is (accounting, the
call is already done) rather than by which error type shows up. Narrowing
would have left 4 of 9 wrapper methods as exceptions to a rule nobody can
remember.
No backend raises it from an accounting method today, so this is a
guardrail for whoever adds source-name validation to a breaker backend.
The stub that first reported this green was wrong: its record_success
lacked count_attempt, so it raised TypeError and the wrapper relabeled it.
Fixed signature, then the test failed as it should have.
Also finishes the three-to-five leak path correction across the four
remaining spots, including the wiki summary card that indexes this design.
Independent verification caught that the split shipped in the previous
commit did not actually hold on the only path production uses. The gate
wrappers re-raise GovernanceBackendError but nothing else, so
SourceNotConfiguredError fell into the following `except Exception` and
came back out as a governance_backend_down failure with retry_after_s=5.0.
A misconfigured source name would still retry forever and never surface.
The existing tests missed it because both of them call the private _cfg()
directly, one layer below the wrapper the governance loops actually go
through. The regression test goes through QuotaGate.
telemetry.py has to widen its terminal catch in the same commit: once the
wrapper stops relabeling the error, it is no longer a GovernanceBackendError,
and it is raised before any attempt exists, so the path would have recorded
no telemetry at all.
Also corrects the leak path count from three to five. QuotaGate.stats and
BreakerGate.retry_after_s are not wrapped by _record_quietly either.
Minor rather than major: adding a parent class widens what an existing
`except` catches, it does not break one. Callers already catching
GovernanceBackendError keep working untouched.
The wiki sync in the release checklist is a no-op this time. The doc site
was taken down entirely on 2026-08-02 for accuracy reasons, and its
remaining landing page points at CHANGELOG.md as the version source of
truth, which this commit updates.
A fail-closed limiter or breaker backend means the scope cannot emit a
single request, which is exactly scope-level unavailability. But the error
sat directly under PolyGatewayError, so a caller writing only
`except GatewayUnavailableError` dropped it into the catch-all branch:
Redis blips once and a backlog of tasks burns its business failure budget
into the dead letter queue, over a fault a restart would clear.
Three gate paths leak to callers rather than being absorbed by
_record_quietly (try_acquire, try_enter, progress_age_s); each is now
pinned by a test, since none of them had one before.
The two unknown-source sites move to SourceNotConfiguredError instead of
following along. They report a misconfigured source name, not an outage,
and letting them into the retryable family would be the mirror of the bug
being fixed here: the task would retry forever and never surface.
Pure addition ahead of the reparenting, so this commit leaves every
existing caller and test untouched.
SourceNotConfiguredError deliberately stays outside GatewayUnavailableError:
a source name that is not in the limiter's config dict is an assembly
defect, not a transient outage, and folding it into the retryable family
would let a typo retry forever without ever reaching a dead letter queue.
The retry_after_s default is 5.0 rather than 0 because a backlog released
at zero delay would stampede a backend that is already down.
Pins the ARCHITECTURE section 6.1 revision to land before or with the
implementation, since the new scope reason contradicts the current single
source of truth. Documents why SourceNotConfiguredError may sit outside
the four-way classification: that rule governs transport-translated call
failures, and the GatewayUnavailableError family already lives outside it.
Also collapses the ten per-field response ternaries in emit_attempt into
an _AttemptUsage view. They all expressed the same decision and pushed the
method to cyclomatic complexity C, which blocked the commit gate.
enable_thinking=False was a silent no-op for minimax and openai sources.
The shape of the switch now stays at provider level while a model-level
capability table says whether a given model can honour it at all, and
reasoning_tokens is collected so the cost of thinking can be told apart
from the cost of answering.
Verified against the live gateway: a seventeen-row matrix over 137 real
calls, kept out of the CI gate behind the slow marker.
The thinking matrix had been running inside make ci all along, which is
not what the design claimed. It takes seven minutes, spends 137 real
calls, and its criteria are statistical, so a network hiccup fails the
build for reasons unrelated to the change under test -- one run died on
three consecutive network errors exhausting the source.
The project already has the mechanism for this: the slow marker, which
addopts excludes by default and the config comments describe as "CI runs
it on demand". Marking the matrix slow brings make ci back down from
seven minutes to ninety seconds while the matrix stays a merge
requirement via -m slow.
The design also claimed e2e does not run in CI. It does: make test runs
pytest over tests/, e2e included, and the existing smoke tests really
call the gateway whenever .env has credentials. Only slow-marked tests
are excluded. Both documents now say so.
Version sources are pyproject and __init__; a test enforces they agree,
and it caught the second one being missed.
The verifier caught that the disable-direction evidence only proved "no
regression", not "actually took effect": on M3 the disabled runs and the
no-opinion baseline are identically distributed, because that model does
not reason by default anyway. So the disable runs alone cannot rule out
the very failure mode issue #5 is about -- the parameter being silently
dropped upstream. The bogus-value experiment that does rule it out was
sitting in the findings document instead of the test suite; it is now
case L3b, and the L3 assertion that could never fail is gone.
Also from the review: the e2e helper caught bare Exception, which would
have disguised a library bug as an unavailable source, exactly the
silence the reporting discipline exists to prevent; the unregistered
model warning fired on every request instead of once per source; and the
transport caught ValueError broadly enough to mislabel unrelated errors,
now narrowed to a dedicated ThinkingUnsupportedError.
The design and plan still described the original judgement criteria,
which the measurements had already overturned. Both now match what the
tests actually do, and the design no longer claims the only new failure
surface is the openai one -- dissect configures MiniMax-M2.7 with
ENABLE_THINKING=false and will fail at assembly, which has to be
coordinated before this merges.
enable_thinking=False was a no-op for minimax and openai sources: both
profiles had empty dicts on each side, so the payload update injected
nothing while the caller believed reasoning had been turned off. A
downstream project was blocked on exactly this.
The root cause is that an empty dict meant two different things -- "no
injection needed" and "we do not know how this provider spells it" --
and that a provider-level table cannot express what turned out to be a
per-model property. Live testing showed MiniMax-M3 can disable
reasoning via reasoning_effort while M2.7 and M2.5 cannot be disabled
at all, which two external registries independently confirm.
So the shape stays at provider level and a capability table joins it at
model level. Unknown, unsupported and no-opinion are now three distinct
values, and resolve_thinking is the single place they meet: it raises at
assembly time when a model cannot honour the request, warns and injects
for unregistered models, and injects silently otherwise. Every registered
capability carries the evidence it was derived from.
enable_thinking also joins the cache fingerprint, since it now really
does change the request body.
Reasoning tokens are already counted inside completion_tokens, so the
cost total was never wrong -- what was missing is the attribution: how
much of a call was spent thinking rather than answering.
LLMResponse and TransportResult each gain a trailing reasoning_tokens
field, and the telemetry port grows from 21 to 22 columns with the new
column appended in both backends so fresh and migrated schemas keep the
same physical order.
None means this particular call did not report the field, not that the
source never reports it: a relay that falls back to a local tokenizer
replaces the whole usage object and drops completion_tokens_details.
Downstream checks must therefore read "in (None, 0)"; no provider was
observed reporting a literal zero.
Both Redis backends have lowercased scope in their own constructors since
v1.0.0, so case never split the keyspace. What actually does is whitespace:
the backends lower but do not strip.
Patch level: no field or env key was removed or renamed, no port
signature moved, and the API stays backward compatible -- what changed
is the telemetry data contract, which the changelog spells out for
downstream cost rollups.
The gate check forced operators to guess a per-call token size before
they could enable the TPM gate at all; est_tokens is now an optional
tuning override and effective_est_tokens() derives the reservation from
the provider quota. Reservation and settlement already read the same
derived value, so the deposit still nets to zero on both the success
path and the non-dead transient failure path.
The rest of _validate_gates is untouched, and the est_tokens field plus
its EST_TOKENS env key stay put for migration compatibility.
Five call sites (QuotaGate entry, RetryMW/EmbeddingClient success and
transient-failure settlement) now read effective_est_tokens() instead of
est_tokens. Success paths gain an unavailable branch that keeps delta at
zero once usage frames may be missing; it has no producer yet, so
behaviour is unchanged while the tpm>0 => est_tokens>0 gate still holds.
Task 1 of the est_tokens decoupling: capability only, no call site
touched, so library behaviour is unchanged word for word.
SourceConfig.effective_est_tokens() returns the explicit est_tokens when
set, otherwise tpm // 60 floored at 1, otherwise 0 when the TPM gate is
off. The divisor is scale free: any quota size yields the same in-flight
ceiling of roughly sixty calls, which is what makes the default
explainable where a fixed constant was not.
USAGE_SOURCES lands with the two assertions the design asks for, not as
a dead constant. test_usage_source_domain.py drives every production
point -- _resolve_usage, _resolve_embedding_usage, _merge and the three
TelemetryEmitter.emit_* helpers -- and asserts the output stays inside
the domain; it is a separate file because the assertion spans
transports, embedding and telemetry, and the innermost kernel test
should not depend on implementations. The second assertion pins the
opposite ruling: constructing LLMResponse with an out-of-domain value
must not raise, since a bare ValueError at a runtime construction point
falls outside the four error categories and would escape chat().
tpm > 0 with est_tokens = 0 is still rejected until Task 4, so the
derivation tests build the future-legal shape through a helper that
bypasses the constraint; the helper collapses back to _make_source once
the constraint is gone.
The verifier found four more env-only behaviours of the same class the branch
was already fixing. The worst is scope: it goes straight into the Redis keys
(pgw:limit:{scope}, pgw:gate:{scope}), so one process using from_env("LLM")
and another constructing scope="LLM" by hand split the rate limit and breaker
state across two namespaces, each tracking its own quota, with no error.
Blank redis_url and pricing_path now collapse to None as from_env has always
done, so they fall into the required-field checks instead of reaching the redis
client as an unparseable URL. EmbeddingSettings gains the __post_init__ it never
had, moving its batch_size and expected_dim checks off the from_env-only path.
Also adds the cache backend whitelist test that mutation testing showed missing.
The warning added earlier in this branch logged the whole Postgres DSN, password
included, and nothing else in the library has ever printed a connection string.
It now reports only the scheme segment, which is the part that actually changed.
Regression test asserts the password and host/path never reach the log.
Round two of the from_env-only validation problem. Fifteen checks still lived
in the env parsing functions: six enum domains, the redis_url requirement for
redis-backed limiter/breaker/cache, cache namespace and TTL, telemetry path and
DSN, non-negative structured retries and non-blank scope. from_settings and
direct construction bypassed all of them.
The five asserts in client.py that claimed config had already validated
redis_url and the telemetry targets now hold on every path, so they revert to
what CLAUDE.md permits: internal invariant declarations that also narrow the
Optional for type checkers. Their comments now name the method that guarantees
them, since the previous wording is exactly what went stale.
Postgres DSNs built by hand now get the SQLAlchemy +driver suffix stripped the
way from_env has always stripped it, with a warning so the rewrite is not
silent. The env path strips earlier, so it stays quiet.
Patch release for the settings invariant fix. The changelog carries a separate
'behaviour tightening' section because a patch number gives downstreams no
warning that construction can now raise where it previously did not.
The lease, stall and probe-TTL guards only ran inside GatewaySettings.from_env,
so from_settings() and direct construction could produce settings that violate
the class's own invariants: the permit lease could expire mid-request (silently
exceeding the concurrency quota), a normal slow first token could be killed as a
stall, and a half-open probe could be taken over while still in flight.
Guards move into __post_init__ as _validate_* methods, matching every frozen
dataclass in types.py, so all six factories plus dataclasses.replace are covered
by one check. Adds a non-empty sources invariant that previously only from_env
enforced. Messages now name fields instead of env keys, since callers who build
settings by hand never set those keys.
iomgaa